Watchdogs give NASA’s manned space strategy gets harsh review

By Michael Cooney, Network World |  Science, NASA

The folks at the Government Accountability Office have not been all that kind to NASA in recent years and today they issued another damming report on the future of the manned space flight program.

NASA is still struggling to develop a solid business case--including firm requirements, mature technologies, a knowledge-based acquisition strategy, a realistic cost estimate, and sufficient funding and time--needed to justify moving the Constellation program, witch includes the two main spaceflight components, the Ares I Crew Launch Vehicle and the Orion Crew Exploration Vehicle, forward into the implementation phase, the GAO stated.

Network World Extra: 10 NASA space technologies that may never see the cosmos

Top 10 cool satellite projects

The GAO cites significant technical and design challenges for the Orion and Ares I vehicles, such as limiting vibration during launch, eliminating the risk of hitting the launch tower during lift off, and reducing the weight of the Orion vehicle that must be overcome in order to meet safety and performance requirements.

The GAO went on to say poorly phased funding that runs the risk of funding shortfalls in fiscal years 2009 through 2012, resulting in planned work not being completed to support schedules and milestones. The overall approach has limited NASA's ability to mitigate technical risks early in development and precludes the orderly ramp up of workforce and developmental activities, the GAO stated.

NASA estimates that Ares I and Orion represent up to $49 billion of the over $97 billion estimated to be spent on the Constellation program through 2020. While the agency has already obligated more than $10 billion in contracts, at this point NASA does not know how much Ares I and Orion will ultimately cost, and will not know until technical and design challenges have been addressed, the GAO concluded.

Regardless of NASA’s final plans for moving forward, the agency faces daunting challenges developing human rated spacecraft for use after the Space Shuttle is retired, and it is important that the agency lay out an acquisition strategy grounded in knowledge-based principles that is executable with acceptable levels of risk within the program’s available budget, the GAO stated.

It is the budget that has the attention of government planers at the moment.

Join us:






Answers - Powered by ITworld

ITworld Answers helps you solve problems and share expertise. Ask a question or take a crack at answering the new questions below.

Ask a Question